Compare the three ways to buy

The payment, the cash to close, and what is left to pay

Cash to Close
Assumption

Assumption only

$2,568/mo
Lowest payment
Down payment
$303,514
Funds due
$316,477
Interest + MI left
$23,875
First ends
Sep 2036
Assumption

Assumption + second

$4,373/mo
+$1,805/mo
Down payment
$51,514
Funds due
$65,995
Interest + MI left
$421,805
First ends
Sep 2036
New loan

New conventional

$3,797/mo
+$1,229/mo
Down payment
$51,514
Funds due
$62,524
Interest + MI left
$670,236
First ends
Jan 2057

Monthly payment

The initial total housing payment for each option.

Assumption onlyAssumption + secondNew conventional
First mortgage$206,386$206,386$458,386
Second mortgage—$252,000—
First P&I$1,968.05$1,968.05$3,105.27
Second P&I—$1,805.36—
Mortgage insurance——$91.68
Taxes, insurance & HOA$600.08$600.08$600.08
Total housing payment$2,568.13$4,373.49$3,797.03

Cash to close

Down payment, closing costs and prepaids, then credits.

Down payment$51,514
Closing costs & prepaids$14,481
Usable credit−$0
Total buyer cash needed$65,995
Earnest money paid−$0
Remaining funds due$65,995
Assumption fee$763.00
Credit report$200.00
Tax service$80.00
UMe assumption specialist (1%)$5,099.00
Title & settlement$1,825.00
Recording fee$100.00
VA funding fee (0.5%)$1,031.93
Second-loan charges$1,250.00
Home insurance (12 months up front)$2,000.00
Insurance escrow (3 months)$500.00
Property tax escrow (3 months)$1,300.25
Prepaid interest, first (5 days)$64.18
Prepaid interest, second (5 days)$267.53

Prepaids include a year of home insurance up front, three months of taxes and insurance in escrow, and 5 days of interest to the end of the closing month.

What is left to pay

The seller already paid down the early, interest-heavy years.

Remaining first mortgage at closing9 yr 9 moOf the original 15-year loan at 2.27%
Interest already paid$30,373Through Dec 2026
Assumption only · ends Sep 2036$23,875
Assumption + second · ends Sep 2036, second Jan 2057$421,805
New conventional · ends Jan 2057$670,236